business

U.S. Loyalty Programs Get More Funding but Fall Short of Expectations

Summarized from All Financial Services & Investing

Businesses are boosting loyalty program investment, but a new arrivia study shows most consumers feel rewards still underdeliver.

U.S. Loyalty Programs Get More Funding but Fall Short of Expectations

American businesses are ramping up spending on customer loyalty programs even as research suggests the return on that investment remains limited by a widening gap between consumer expectations and actual program performance, according to new data from arrivia.

The survey found that nine in ten U.S. consumers expect to remain loyal to their preferred brand or organization, a figure that signals strong underlying appetite for rewards relationships. Yet only 32% of respondents said their loyalty program consistently exceeds expectations, indicating that most programs are leaving significant engagement value on the table.

Read more Huawei Showcases AI Scalability Tools for Banks at Singapore FinTech Festival →

The disconnect points to a structural challenge for brands: investment alone does not translate into satisfaction. Consumers appear willing to commit to companies they favor, but they are increasingly demanding more tangible, personalized, or flexible rewards in return for that commitment.

For loyalty program managers, the arrivia findings suggest that growing budgets may need to be redirected toward program quality and relevance rather than simple scale. As competition for consumer attention intensifies, companies that fail to close the expectation gap risk losing members to rival programs that better deliver on their promises.

Continue reading at All Financial Services & Investing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q.What percentage of consumers say their loyalty program exceeds expectations?

Only 32% of U.S. consumers surveyed by arrivia said their rewards program consistently exceeds expectations.

Q.How loyal do U.S. consumers plan to be to their preferred brands?

According to arrivia's research, 90% of consumers expect to remain loyal to their preferred brand or organization.

Q.Who conducted the loyalty program research?

The research was conducted by arrivia, a loyalty and travel rewards company, with findings released in November 2026.

More in business →